A note for those of you reading: Mismatched Sox is a weekly blog hastily thrown together by Sox in the Basement Co-Host Ed Siebert and is written to present you with White Sox and baseball thoughts in a manner that, frankly, thinks it is funny in the way that your aunt misuses memes. While there will be facts here that will be factual, the opinions and other nonsense are neither reflective of anyone at SoxInTheBasement.com nor believed or intended to cause any harm, but consult a physician and ask if this blog is right for you.

Grinding to a halt does not adequately describe the CBA negotiations, because something has to have ever gotten moving to grind to a halt. For as frustrated as the players are portraying themselves, there’s little comparison to the frustration felt by fans. And the kicker there is that fans want to spend their time and money on these guys who are using the media (both social and, ummm, anti-social?) to blame the other for not sharing enough of the fans’ money. So, in lieu of being able to mediate, here’s an open letter to both sides that will hopefully heal the wounds of distrust and bring forth the type of togetherness that usually requires stitches and wearing a plastic bag in the shower.
February 10, 2022
Sox on 35th/Sox in the Basement C/O Mismatched Sox Pueblo, CO 81009
MLB and MLBPA C/O Scott Boras, 18 Corporate Plaza Dr, Newport Beach, CA 92660
Dear Gentlemen and Assorted Others:
This letter is intended to help. Help, and heal. Help, heal and hold hope. Help, heal, hold hope and hell, maybe even hope to help heal your holdings.
No, actually, that’s not true. There’s no helping you people, is there? There’s no way you can help yourselves let alone have others hope to help heal…
Sorry, starting over. This letter is going to let you know exactly how fans feel about you about what is happening to Major League Baseball. There are words that adequately describe the turmoil fans feel, but basically, those words would make George Carlin blush, were he alive to do so.
As fans, we are aware that you don’t think we are capable of understanding the plight of either side. That’s a very narrow view and rather arrogant, don’t you think? Do you really think fans can’t appreciate that the players want to be fairly compensated for their efforts? Talk to anyone working for a living and they’ll understand that. Do you really think fans can’t understand that the owners aren’t in the business of losing money? Sure, it is hard to fathom that teams aren’t profitable, but on a basic level, Americans who have lived in a free market understand that businesses need to make enough money to stay afloat.
What fans kinda can’t always wrap their heads around is the difference between making a million here or 10 million there. Beyond, of course, a basic understanding of numbers and some being bigger than others. But the difference between rich and richer is lost on most people. The average fan is probably in that lovely gray water pool of stagnant wages that haven’t risen much at all since the 1970s, and are on average underpaid compared to the cost of living. So yes, as a result, most fans are largely unaware of the mo’ problems that your mo’ money causes you to see. But that, shockingly, isn’t the source of anger.
In fact, here is a shortlist of things that the average fan would be angrier about than the fact that baseball players and owners are comparatively rich:
1) gas prices
2) the ongoing national chicken wing shortage
3) snow falling off a roof or branch and trickling down the back of their shirt
4) politics
5) when shows have 2-part seasons
6) that snow making it into their pants
7) Linda’s coffee (seriously Linda, let Bill do it)
8) their kids’ attitude
9) the Doordash/Uber/Grubhub driver giving them the wrong order
10) that same said snow coming to life and overtaking their body for evil purposes, but not in a fun way.
Nope, fans don’t care about the money. They have evil snow underwear issues to deal with, hence the need for the diversion that baseball provides. It is a few hours a day where fans can forget that they are freezing the guards and cops at the bank and can’t stop the mystical chilly evil within from using their hands against their will and besmirching their very name and reputation, and instead worry about whether Dylan Cease can go 6 today because the bullpen needs a blow after yesterday.
See, that’s where you start to annoy fans. You forget what you are, which is entertainment and diversion from everyday problems that frankly, you players and owners lack. I mean, we all have the same issues with relationships, kids, eye boogers, evil snow thongs, etc., but there are stresses in life that some have that others don’t. Baseball is a great leveler of society, where people with bad problems and people who just are being a tad dramatic about their problems can shed the stress the same way. Look, players, owners, you are just purveyors of entertainment. And being truthful, you’re dropping rapidly in the line of things that people turn to these days for entertainment.
Owners in particular pay attention, because you were alive and probably an adult in 1994 when the last stoppage cost a season and should know better. Players, while most of you were either toddlers or still just a future apathetic shrug by your mom in 1994, pay attention anyway because this involves you. In 1994, there were four major TV networks, 139 cable TV networks (most of which were meh), movies, the NFL, the NBA, the NHL, video games, books, and periodicals. Frankly, not much competition for our attention. The strike sent baseball way down the list and fans didn’t come back right away. To get back towards the top of that heap, you had to enter a period in the game that is now disdained by fans and writers, the “Steroid Era”. And don’t think some of us haven’t noticed that steroid testing is ending. Speaking on behalf of White Sox fans, if steroids come back and suddenly Gavin Sheets, Adam Engel, and Dallas Keuchel are the new McGwire, Sosa, and Clemens…we’ll turn a blind eye and defend them publicly while giving Yankee fans crap about Luke Voit suddenly being healthy all the time. But we’ll know the truth, and in 30 years we’ll be huffy about it, but mostly we’ll know what you did.
But that’s not the point. The point is that it took extreme head growth and other measures to get the game back in the fans’ good graces in 1995, and frankly, we were bored in the ’90s. Today, you have TV, Cable, Streaming Services (139 of them?) the internet, Wordle, movies, video games on phones that also have the internet and streaming services, including streaming cable, movies, and regular TV, more books and blogs and news and it goes on. Frankly, baseball, you’re behind the NFL by a mile and behind a number of other entertainment options. Heck, you’re probably behind pro wrestling, which boomed in the late ’90s. Baseball, this is serious. Really. You’re in real danger of being replaced in popularity by Jason Bateman shows. In 1994, Jason Bateman couldn’t get a show as an extra. Now he’s your sworn enemy!
But fans aren’t mad that you’re maybe definitely losing the battle for the attention of the masses. Baseball fans are fans because of what the game is, not whether it is trendy. And if we’re honest, the masses right now lack taste in entertainment. They make celebrities out of people who succeed at being attractive while doing something largely unoriginal for 15 seconds on the internet, but doing that a lot. Still, that’s a rabbit hole that can consume the same hours that a baseball game consumes and at a lot less cost.
So owners and players, your lack of perspective is what’s making your fan base mad. There was no real urgency to get a deal done, there’s a lockout and brinkmanship and public whining, but no real perspective. You think that this battle is important, but it isn’t. The game, the league, the shared history and experience, that’s important. Fans want you. Fans want you bad. But we don’t need you. So we want you, but only if you want us. We want you, to want us. To quote Cheap Trick further, we are shinin’ up our old brown shoes, puttin’ on a brand new shirt, and gettin’ home early from work…if you say, that you love us. And after decades of listening to that song the question arises why this person is getting all dressed up to go home. That’s a digression though.
Back to the point, and to quote the band Extreme and their magnum opus “More Than Words”:
More than words to show you feel
That your love for me is real
What would you say
If I took those words away?
Then you couldn’t make things new
Just by saying “I love you”
La-di-da, da-di-da di-dai-dai-da, indeed. See, players, when you tweet that you want to be there for us and say that if the owners would only make an offer that you’d play, it’s a touch hollow. Because you didn’t just take a deal and get back on the field; you countered and had real divides on the issues. And owners, y’all better not pretend that you’re doing this for the fans because we aren’t being served by sitting around waiting. You haven’t done much to even try and resolve this. Fans don’t want to watch you protect your bottom line, fans want to have the chance to contribute to it. All we ask is for an interesting team, cold drinks on hot days, hot drinks on cold days, cold drinks on cold days because some of them have a warming effect, reasonably priced unhealthy food, and seats that can fit a huskier build. No one asked you to give Max Scherzer or Trevor Bauer enough money per year to purchase Lichtenstein. You set those expectations years ago and you need to accept the consequences. Primarily, the consequence is that the team is a very expensive hobby, and maybe your income is better off coming from whatever you did to be able to afford a baseball team in the first place. That’s maybe unfair, but blaming the majority of players for wanting a piece of what you’ve handed out to a select few of their peers is human nature. That’s why you bring enough gum for everybody, regardless of their spin rate or whether they kinda creep you out.
Why are fans mad? Because we are left here realizing that for as much heart and emotion as fans put into the game, it isn’t returned to us in equal measure. Fans are kids watching mom and dad fight, and knowing that it is more important to each of them that the kids publicly side with them instead of making sure that the fans understand that this isn’t their fault and we’ll get ice cream and t-shirt giveaways after this.
That’s admittedly a bleak note to end the letter on, and this was intended to help heal the hellish holdup (hey! there it is!). So, here are some words of encouragement, and most of them are even mostly sincere:
You are all, owners and players, intelligent, attractive, charming, and incredibly talented people who are at the pinnacle of humanity. You are the brightest, shiniest beacon of hope for those who can only aspire to your heights. Your civility and willingness to show us that people can overcome great adversity to achieve common greatness that lifts the world, nay the universe itself, the way the tide raises all boats great and small. Knowing this, knowing thyselves to be superior, quit being a bunch of whiny self-important buttheads and get some perspective; none of us care about your petty little squabbles, we just want to give you our money so for at least a little while we can forget the giant suckhole that is life in 2022. And if Jason Bateman can do that for us, you can too.
Yours in crushing mediocrity,
But One Fan Amongst Many
Ed Siebert
cc Jason Bateman
Featured Photo: @whitesox / Twitter






